Shortcuts

Connect with us on Facebook!
Subscribe.
[Feeds & Readers]

Make us your home page!
Authors, sign in!

« Why I Support Obama | Main | Financial Crisis Hits Students »


Anatomy of a Personal Debate

By Bill Shanahan
October 10, 2008

My profound regret is how much the YouTube video of me hurt FHSU. I again offer my sincerest apology and take full responsibility for my behavior while defending myself and my students.

I will always value highly the opportunity to work with tremendous students, the generous funding and support that allowed me to help build a nationally renowned debate program, and the extraordinary professional relationships that pushed me to become a better academic and person.

The last claim, about becoming a better person, certainly will be challenged by those of you who have come to despise me, even before my transgressions at the CEDA national debate tournament in March.

Early on, after a confrontation with Gene Anderson, I received a death threat. I have never been shy about expressing my opinions. I was raised in a different culture, one which values openness and honesty. Still, that plain envelope with no return address gave me pause. Where was I?

I should have known my time here would be different when after only a couple of days, two of my new department colleagues likened my not wearing shoes in August to a previous graduate student who prowled the school cafeteria eating food left behind on trays. Where was I, indeed?

The hate mail became a regular feature of my life in Hays, especially after I accepted an invitation from John Montgomery to write a Local Voices column. I have cherished this opportunity, despite the vitriol it generates and the consternation that vitriol causes my wife, Kim.

Building and sustaining one of the most competitive debate teams in the country came at a terrifically high cost. From August until April for 10 years, I worked three times more hours on debate that I was paid. The work was unbelievably rigorous and took almost everything I had, intellectually and physically.

Twelve- to 14-hour competition days, four day weekends plus travel, and every weekend consumed by either tournaments or preparation took their toll over the 24 years I have been a college debate coach. I loved the work and the challenge. I especially enjoyed working with the students.

College debate has come under intense scrutiny since my trial by our viral media. Another in my long list of regrets is the harsh criticism aimed at my beloved activity. Ed Hammond is leading the charge to "reform" debate, and he is gravely misguided.

Debate has been my intellectual home since high school. I thought I was in a safe house when at a tournament. I thought I was among people who understood how important our activity was and how much we needed to protect it. I was sadly mistaken.

Hammond indicts this protective insularity as further proof that debate has gone astray. He is dead wrong. The harsh outside light of misinformed scrutiny will do far more damage than good.

Debate flourished as an enclave of genuine academic freedom and unfettered intellectual inquiry. His "movement" will destroy that if he is successful, though I doubt it will be. Debate always finds a way.

I said I was sorry for the damage done and I am, more than I could ever express. I am also intensely angry. I was tried in a media that is as slavishly devoted to titillation as it is committed to filling its now 24-hour "news" cycle. Media today is viral -- that is, irresponsible, voracious and deadly.

I am particularly angry a student and ex-coach could hold my university hostage to their perverse desire for retribution, orchestrate a media circus to inflict maximal damage, and that my administration would knowingly accede. I hoped for more from FHSU. I hoped for reciprocal loyalty and protection. Instead, I got a settlement.

Of course, I understand FHSU expected more from me, too. More than what, though? I sacrificed my personal life and my scholarship to build a great debate program. We were a tiny squad that won a national championship against the best schools in the country.

Students are not faint flowers who wilt at any criticism or the first utterance of profanity. They live online where they are constantly exposed to extreme sexuality, rampant nudity and language far coarser than I uttered.

For as long as I have been involved, debate has resisted that outrageous hypocrisy. We taught students in ways they could relate and in language they understood. We engaged them with relentless criticism and they were better for it. Debaters are among the best thinkers colleges help to educate today.

I truly regret that video engendered so much negative publicity for FHSU and debate, but I am not ashamed of who I am, nor am I apologetic for being the best teacher and coach I knew how to be.

And, I will not go gentle into that good night.


Post your own comment

(To create links here or for style, you may wish to use HTML tags in your comments)

Want to browse more blogs? Try our table of contents to find articles under specific topics or headings. Or you might find interesting entries by looking through the complete archives too. Stay around awhile. We're glad you're here.


Browse the Blogs!

You are here!

This page contains only one entry posted to Everyday Citizen on October 10, 2008 12:08 AM.

The blog post previous to it is titled "Why I Support Obama"

The post that follows this one is titled "Financial Crisis Hits Students"

Want to explore this site more?

Many more blog posts can be found on our Front Page or within our complete Archives.

Does a particular subject interest you?

You can easily search for blog posts under a specific topic by using our List of Categories.

Visit our friends!

Books You Might Like!

Notices & Policies

All of the Everyday Citizen authors are delighted you are here. We all hope that you come back often, leave us comments, and become an active part of our community. Welcome!

All of our contributing authors are credentialed by invitation only from the editor/publisher of EverydayCitizen.com. If you are visiting and are interested in writing here, please feel free to let us know.

For complete site policies, including privacy, see our Frequently Asked Questions. This site is designed, maintained, and owned by its publisher, Everyday Citizen Media. EverydayCitizen.com, The Everyday Citizen, everydaycitizens.com, and Everyday Citizen are trademarked names.

Each of the authors here retain their own copyrights for their original written works, original photographs and art works. Our authors also welcome and encourage readers to copy, reference or quote from the content of their blog postings, provided that the content reprints include obvious author or website attribution and/or links to their original postings, in accordance with this website's Creative Commons License.

Copyright, 2007-2009, All rights reserved, unless otherwise specified, first by each the respective authors of each of their own individual blogs and works, and then by the editor and publisher for any otherwise unreserved and all other content. Our editor primarily reviews blogs for spelling, grammar, punctuation and formatting and is not liable or responsible for the opinions expressed by individual authors. The opinions and accuracy of information in the individual blog posts on this site are the sole responsibility of each of the individual authors.