Dear Editor:

I would like to take issue with the American Israel Public Relations Committee (AIPAC) with regards to its constant bashing of Representative James P. Moran ("Moran Upsets Jewish Groups Again," Saturday, September 15, 2007). The fact is that AIPAC cannot stomach any criticism of itself or the State of Israel and brands anyone who dares to speak up as either anti-Semitic, if one is not Jewish, or as a self-hating Jew, if one is.

Anyone who knows anything about Middle Eastern politics knows that AIPAC wields unyielding and unequaled power in the discussion. As soon as anyone steps over the line - that is, criticizes Israel for its role in Middle Eastern instability - AIPAC immediately shuts down all discussion by using the rubrics mentioned above. This is not only deceitful, for no government or state is a saint, but it also demonstrates contempt for free-speech and democratic ideals, the very ideals the State of Israel was founded on.

The fact is that until an open and frank discussion can be held regarding the underlying issues in the Middle East that have led to instability in the region, the rise of terrorism, and the rise of rogue leaders such as the current Iranian president - i.e. the illegitimate occupation of Palestinian lands by Israel - AIPAC will continue to exercise unparalleled influence in American politics.

The time now is not for name calling. The time now is for peace - peace for Israel, peace for the Palestinians and peace for the Middle East. If we can only achieve that, half the battle against terrorism will have been achieved.

Sincerely,
Mike Maggio

The letter was edited but the gist was clearly maintained.

I expected a flood of hate mail, as would be typical of AIPAC and its supporters. Instead, I received a couple of very supportive emails, and a lively discussion was begun on the Post's discussion board which was also, for the most part, supportive of my views. (You can view the printed letter at this link washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/09/19/AR2007091901969.html as well as the posted comments by clicking on the View All Comments link on that page).

Because this is an issue that had frustrated me for years and because of the unexpected response I received, I thought I would open up the discussion again here at the Everyday Citizen forum.

Your comments, negative or positive, will be greatly appreciated. An open a frank discussion is needed, not only about AIPAC but about the Middle East situation in general. Perhaps we can add our voices and incite peace.